What Should Your A1C Goal Be if You Have Diabetes?
Ken D. Berry, MD, family physician
Published 11/16/26
People with diabetes get so many mixed messages that many give up. In this video I review a New York Times article that tells older people they may not need to watch blood sugar so closely. From much research we know that the lower your A1C, the lower your risk of diabetic complications, type 1 or type 2. The missing piece in that article is diet. Aggressive drug control and a very low carbohydrate diet are not the same tool.
What did the New York Times article argue?
The piece is titled along the lines of why older people may not need to watch blood sugar so closely. It follows an older patient with repeated lows. Her endocrinologist and primary doctor worry about falls, broken bones, heart arrhythmia, and cognitive damage from hypoglycemia, and they advise letting her A1C sit above 7.
Those harms of severe lows are real if you manage diabetes with aggressive pharmaceuticals. They are not the same story if you manage blood sugar the way I teach.
Where did the "relax the A1C" idea come from?
A lot of this goes back to the ACCORD trial, published in 2008. That trial used very intensive medication therapy, heavy on insulin and sulfonylureas such as glyburide, plus another drug later restricted over safety concerns, to force A1C down. In that setting, tight drug-driven control raised hypoglycemia risk. If that is how you lower A1C, then yes, the article's warnings matter.
Why does the article's advice fall apart on a low carb diet?
Millions of people now use low carb, keto, ketovore, or carnivore eating to control type 1 diabetes with much less insulin, or to reverse type 2 diabetes so they need no diabetes drugs at all. In that setting, hypoglycemia largely ceases to be the same concern. Lows in diabetes usually happen when medication overshoots the carbs you ate. Take away the need for aggressive insulin and sulfonylureas, and you take away most of that particular danger.
The article barely mentions diet. There is no serious discussion of low carb, keto, or carnivore, even though, in my view, a very low carbohydrate diet is among the most studied dietary interventions for diabetes control and reversal.
What about the 7.5 to 8 A1C target for older adults?
Groups such as the American Geriatrics Society have called for A1C goals in a higher band for many older adults. In my view that target is a disaster if it means you keep eating a high carbohydrate pattern and accept years of high sugar damage. In my view, an A1C stuck in that higher band means a much higher chance of losing toes or feet, losing kidney function, going blind, or fighting infections that will not heal.
If you are older and still want to live, I want you to know another option exists. With a very low carbohydrate diet and, for many type 2 patients, no diabetes medication, many people can bring A1C under the prediabetes line. That puts complication risk closer to the baseline of people without diabetes.
Am I saying aggressive insulin is fine in seniors?
No. I agree you should not chase a perfect A1C with aggressive insulin, glyburide, or glipizide in older patients. That path causes lows, falls, wrecked cars, and lost licenses. Deintensifying those drugs makes sense when the diet is fixed. Deintensifying while you still eat the rainbow and drink fruit juice is not the same thing.
What about Ozempic in that article?
The article also brings in modern weight-loss diabetes shots. In my view that keeps the conversation inside pharmaceuticals and away from the dietary strategy that removes the need for so many of them.
What should you do instead?
Look into a low carbohydrate diet, a very low carb ketogenic diet, a ketovore diet, or a carnivore diet. Type 2 patients can often wean and stop diabetes medications with their doctor's help. Type 1 patients can often cut insulin needs sharply, lower hypoglycemia risk, and run a more normal A1C. That is how I want you to think about A1C goals, not "7.5 is fine because a newspaper said so."
This is not medical advice. Work with your own doctor before you change medications or diet, especially if you use insulin or drugs that can cause lows.
Frequently asked questions
Is an A1C of 7.5 fine because I am over 70?
In my view, not if that number comes from a high carbohydrate diet and acceptance of ongoing sugar damage. A higher A1C target is mainly a hedge against drug-induced lows, not proof that high sugar is harmless.
Why do doctors fear low blood sugar so much?
Severe hypoglycemia is dangerous. Falls, arrhythmias, and cognitive injury are real. That fear is tied to aggressive insulin and sulfonylurea use, not to well-formulated low carb eating with little or no such medication.
Can type 2 diabetes really go away on low carb?
Many people reverse type 2 diabetes markers on very low carbohydrate eating and no longer need diabetes drugs. We have hundreds of people in our community who have reversed their type 2 diabetes and kept it reversed., and it is why diet belongs in this conversation.
What about type 1?
Type 1 still needs insulin. A very low carbohydrate diet often lets people use substantially less insulin with more stable sugars and lower hypoglycemia risk.
Did the New York Times mention keto or carnivore?
Not in any meaningful way. That omission is the main reason I made the video.
Research referenced in the video
I discuss the ACCORD trial by name and review a New York Times article. These are the links I could verify.
Action to Control Cardiovascular Risk in Diabetes Study Group, Gerstein HC, Miller ME, et al. (2008), "Effects of intensive glucose lowering in type 2 diabetes": https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18539917/
Paula Span, The New York Times (2025), "Why Older People May Not Need to Watch Blood Sugar So Closely": https://www.nytimes.com/2025/03/10/health/diabetes-blood-sugar-age.html
About Dr. Berry
Dr. Ken Berry is a board-certified family physician who has cared for over 25,000 patients in more than two decades of practice in rural Tennessee. He grew up in Hohenwald, Tennessee, and earned his MD at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center.
He is the author of the #1 bestselling Lies My Doctor Told Me and the creator of the Proper Human Diet.
He lives on a farm in Holladay, Tennessee, with his wife Neisha and their two children.