Carnivore or Keto: Which Is Better for You?
Ken D. Berry, MD, family physician
Published 11/16/26
It depends. Carnivore versus keto is not a debate. It is a choice, and there are reasons to make one choice over the other. Keto is a very low carbohydrate, moderate protein, higher fat diet that allows some low carb vegetables, nuts, and a few berries. Carnivore is only meat and eggs, plus or minus fish. I ate keto for a few years and loved it, and I have eaten carnivore for years and loved that too.
What is a keto diet?
Keto is a very low carbohydrate, moderate protein, higher fat diet. It allows some plant foods: low carb vegetables, nuts, and a few berries. It keeps you in a state of ketosis for the majority of each and every day.
When I say keto, I mean a real whole food ketogenic diet. Half your plate is covered with fatty meat and eggs with yolk, half is covered with low carb vegetables, and you have a few nuts and a few berries for dessert. I am not talking about keto bread, keto cookies, keto cake, keto pie, or keto toilet paper. Anything at the supermarket with keto on the front of the label most assuredly is not keto.
What is a carnivore diet?
A carnivore diet is made up of only meat and eggs, plus or minus fish, that is unbreaded and not fried in vegetable seed oils. It is a very low carbohydrate diet, even lower than keto. It is essentially zero carbohydrate if you do not count the glycogen stored in muscle and organ meat.
It is basically the ultimate elimination diet, because meat and eggs are some of the least inflammatory foods on the planet.
Who is keto a good fit for?
In my view, keto is a good fit for:
- People transitioning off the standard American diet who feel carnivore is a little too aggressive right now.
- People who still like vegetables and want some variety. There is much less variety on carnivore.
- People without severe inflammation or severe autoimmune conditions.
- People who want to lose 20, 30, or 40 pounds.
- People with prediabetes, hyperinsulinemia, slightly high blood pressure, or who are a little overweight.
Anybody with prediabetes or type 2 diabetes is going to benefit tremendously from a ketogenic diet. The same goes for people with high blood pressure, metabolic syndrome, overweight, or obesity. Many people with chronic inflammatory conditions in the gut, skin, or joints also benefit, because keto removes processed food and ultra-processed food, eliminates most of the sugar, including all added sugar, removes all the grains and most of the beans, and removes all the vegetable seed oils.
Those people can also eat a carnivore diet if they are happy eating meat and eggs every day. That is also a viable option.
What are the social benefits of keto?
It is easier to eat in a mixed setting. If you are invited to dinner or a family reunion, eating keto does not look as controversial as eating carnivore, where you have a plate of just meat. If your spouse is not on board with carnivore, meat-heavy keto is a good option. You can say, "See, there is the broccoli. I am eating vegetables."
It can also be a compromise with your doctor, who may say that cholesterol and saturated fat will kill you on carnivore. I think a real whole food ketogenic diet is a rational compromise.
Who should choose carnivore over keto?
In my view, carnivore is the better choice if:
- You have tried keto for a few months and you are still struggling, or your conditions are better but not gone.
- You have a severe sugar addiction. Some things in a ketogenic diet can call the monkey back up on your back.
- You have severe autoimmune disease, or severe chronic gut or joint issues. Carnivore is probably what you want to try first.
- You are desperate for faster weight loss, a faster drop in your A1C, or faster reversal of your chronic conditions. Many people find carnivore quicker than keto.
Carnivore is made for people with severe inflammation in the gut, skin, or joints, for people with a severe carbohydrate addiction, and for people with food intolerances.
What is the most important rule for picking a diet?
The only diet that works for you is the diet you can sustain long term. If eating only meat and eggs sounds terrible to you and you know you will not stay on it, do not even try carnivore.
What are the common keto mistakes?
The most common keto mistake is falling for keto bread, keto treats, keto cookies, and keto junk food, thinking that since it says keto in the name, it must be keto. This is a marketing ploy. Companies put keto on the package because it is popular right now.
Keto is real whole food only. It is very common for people to be ketoish, dirty keto, or sort of keto, and you will not get much benefit from that because you are still eating a lot of ultra-processed junk food.
What are the common carnivore mistakes?
- Eating too lean. Eat at least as much fat as comes with the lean, and cook in bacon grease or butter, or put butter on top. A lean carnivore diet leaves you with low energy and is not sustainable. You need enough fat to make it delicious and to get the energy you are hoping for.
- Cheating on weekends with low carb vegetables when you have severe autoimmune disease or severe inflammation. For many people it is the vegetables causing at least part of the inflammation. If you are starting carnivore for those conditions, be strict.
The easiest way to be strict is to eat nothing but beef, butter, bacon, and eggs, and cook everything in animal fats. If you eat something else, you chose to. You were not misled by marketing. If that happens, forgive yourself right away and get back on the carnivore train. The only thing worse than a cheat meal is a cheat meal that turns into a cheat day, a cheat week, or a cheat month.
Should you go carnivore overnight or move there slowly?
Many people do better moving slowly from an ultra-processed junk food diet to a low carb diet, then a real whole food ketogenic diet, then a ketovore diet, and later, if they still need more healing, to strict carnivore. If you are a moderate person, you probably want to wean down the carbohydrates and plant foods slowly.
If you are a teetotaler, there is nothing dangerous or bad about going carnivore overnight. If you are a severe sugar addict, you might get withdrawals. As long as you know they are sugar withdrawals, you can call them what they are and fight them. If you do not know what they are, they can worry you into quitting carnivore.
This is not medical advice. Work with your own doctor.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better, carnivore or keto?
It depends on your goals, your level of inflammation, and the life you actually live. Whichever you pick, you are doing better than most people who are still eating the standard diet.
Do I have to choose keto first?
No. Keto is easier to transition into from the standard American diet. But if you are happy eating meat and eggs, a carnivore diet is also a viable option, even overnight if you are a teetotaler.
Can I eat vegetables on carnivore?
Not on a strict carnivore diet. If you have severe autoimmune or severe inflammatory conditions, I think you need to be strict, because for many people vegetables are part of the inflammation.
Is keto bread keto?
No. Keto bread, cookies, cake, and pie are marketing. Real keto is whole food only.
What if I slip up?
There is no failure, only feedback and temporary stumbles. Forgive yourself right away and get right back on the keto or carnivore train.
Research referenced in the video
I discuss the ACCORD trial by name and review a New York Times article. These are the links I could verify.
Action to Control Cardiovascular Risk in Diabetes Study Group, Gerstein HC, Miller ME, et al. (2008), "Effects of intensive glucose lowering in type 2 diabetes": https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18539917/
Paula Span, The New York Times (2025), "Why Older People May Not Need to Watch Blood Sugar So Closely": https://www.nytimes.com/2025/03/10/health/diabetes-blood-sugar-age.html
About Dr. Berry
Dr. Ken Berry is a board-certified family physician who has cared for over 25,000 patients in more than two decades of practice in rural Tennessee. He grew up in Hohenwald, Tennessee, and earned his MD at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center.
He is the author of the #1 bestselling Lies My Doctor Told Me and the creator of the Proper Human Diet.
He lives on a farm in Holladay, Tennessee, with his wife Neisha and their two children.