Is Oatmeal Really Good for You? 

Ken D. Berry, MD, family physician

Published 11/16/26

In my opinion, no. Oatmeal is less bad for you than Lucky Charms, but that does not make it a superfood. The small drop in LDL cholesterol you get from oats is wiped out by the blood sugar spikes oatmeal causes, and the antinutrients in oats keep you from absorbing much of what is on the nutrition label.

Recently the New York Times published an article calling oats a nutritional superstar and a staple of wellness culture. It said oats are great for your heart, your blood sugar, and your gut, and it pointed out that oats are backed by the FDA. I call that health washing. Here are the three big lies about oatmeal: two explicit lies and one lie by implication.

Is oatmeal heart healthy?

This is lie number one. The claim is that oatmeal protects you from a heart attack or heart failure because it contains beta-glucans, which can lower LDL cholesterol.

There is about 3 grams of beta-glucan in a half-cup bowl of rolled oats. That can lower LDL cholesterol by a small amount. But that reduction is minor, and it has not translated into people actually having fewer heart attacks or strokes. The New York Times called it a significant benefit. In reality it is very small.

How many bowls would you need to eat to lower LDL enough to provably lower your heart attack risk? In my view, many bowls a day. If you ate that much oatmeal, your blood sugar would be off the charts all day long, and that would cancel out any benefit from the LDL lowering.

Does oatmeal support healthy blood sugar?

This is lie number two. Any time someone says a food "supports" something, in my view that is a colloquialism for BS. Nothing about oats supports your blood sugar.

The idea is that beta-glucan slows digestion of the oats and keeps your blood sugar from spiking as high as it otherwise would. Oats do have some beta-glucan and some fiber, and that slows the spike a little. It does not stop it.

Look at the recipes in that New York Times article: overnight oats, oatmeal cookies, and slow cooker steel-cut oats with fruit, natural sweeteners, or honey. All of these are full of sugar and starch. They turn into blood sugar, spike your blood sugar, and therefore spike your insulin.

Most people with any degree of insulin resistance, metabolic syndrome, or hyperinsulinemia will see a significant spike in their blood sugar 30 minutes, 60 minutes, and up to 2 hours after a bowl of oatmeal. People report big spikes on their meters and continuous glucose monitors after eating that "heart-healthy" bowl.

Why do blood sugar spikes matter for your heart?

When your blood sugar spikes, your insulin spikes to pull it back down. High blood sugar also causes glycation in the cells and tissues of your body, and daily spikes cause inflammation and damage inside your arteries, including the arteries that feed your heart.

So oatmeal lowers LDL a little bit and spikes your blood sugar a lot. In my view, the spike completely cancels any benefit from the lower LDL. Prediabetes, type 2 diabetes, insulin resistance, and hyperinsulinemia are, in my opinion, far more dangerous than elevated LDL cholesterol. I go over the hazard ratios in my video called How Not to Die of a Heart Attack. The LDL-lowering effect of oatmeal is a triviality for your overall heart health.

Is oatmeal a nutrient-dense superfood?

This is lie number three, the lie by implication. Oats are mostly starch by dry weight, and only a small fraction is beta-glucan. Starch is long chains of glucose holding hands. An enzyme in your mouth and belly called amylase breaks starch apart into glucose, which is blood sugar.

Researchers love to focus on the small beta-glucan fraction and ignore the high starch content and the added sugar most people put on oatmeal. Maple syrup, agave nectar, and honey are all pure sugar.

What are the antinutrients in oats?

Oats contain protein, vitamins, and minerals, but they also contain antinutrients. These are plant chemicals that can block your body from absorbing vitamins and minerals, make it hard to digest the protein, and cause inflammation you are not told about. In the video I list:

  • Phytic acid, the biggest issue. It binds strongly to iron, zinc, calcium, and magnesium and makes them insoluble, so your body cannot absorb them well.
  • Saponins and tannins, which interfere with protein digestion and lock up minerals even more.
  • Oxalates, lectins, and other compounds that can block your digestive enzymes and make the protein in oatmeal hard to use.

So you do not actually absorb the iron, zinc, calcium, magnesium, and protein listed on the side of the oatmeal container.

There is a second-order problem too. If you eat oatmeal with bacon and eggs, which I consider superfoods full of vitamins, minerals, and protein, the antinutrients in the oatmeal can block absorption from the eggs and bacon as well.

What is avenin, and can it cause inflammation?

Avenin is the storage protein in oats. You have probably heard of gluten and gliadin, the storage proteins in wheat. Many people are sensitive to them and get gut, joint, skin, or even brain inflammation when they eat wheat.

There has been some limited research on oats and avenin in people with celiac disease, and it suggests that a subset of those people may react to oats. But no one has studied whether regular folks have an inflammatory response to avenin. In my view, there could be many people with an avenin sensitivity, just like a gluten sensitivity, who get bloating, gas, and gut discomfort and never blame the oatmeal. If any nutrition researchers are reading, that study needs to be done.

How can you test oatmeal on yourself?

Make any of the New York Times recipes, or any oatmeal you like. Check your blood sugar before you eat it, then again at 30 minutes and 60 minutes after. Watch your blood sugar go up. That is a spike. If you try it, I want to hear your actual numbers in the comments on the video.

If you are young and metabolically perfectly healthy, maybe you can eat an occasional bowl of oatmeal if you actually like it. For anyone with metabolic illness, oatmeal is not a superfood, and in my opinion it is not good for you.

This is not medical advice. Work with your own doctor on your health and medications.

Frequently asked questions

Does oatmeal lower cholesterol?

The beta-glucan in oats can lower LDL cholesterol a little. That small drop has not been shown to mean fewer heart attacks or strokes, and in my view the blood sugar spike cancels it out.

Does oatmeal spike blood sugar?

Yes. Most people with insulin resistance, metabolic syndrome, or hyperinsulinemia see a significant spike at 30 minutes, 60 minutes, and up to 2 hours after a bowl of oatmeal. The fiber slows the spike a little but does not stop it.

Is steel-cut or overnight oatmeal healthier?

The recipes in the New York Times article, including overnight oats and slow cooker steel-cut oats with fruit or honey, are full of sugar and starch. They still turn into blood sugar and spike your insulin.

Can oats cause a reaction like gluten does?

Oats contain their own storage protein, avenin. Limited research suggests a subset of people with celiac disease may react to oats, and in my view many other people may be sensitive to avenin without knowing it.

Is oatmeal better than sugary cereal?

Oatmeal is less bad for you than Lucky Charms. Being less bad than a sugar-sweetened cereal does not make it good, and it does not make it a superfood.

Research referenced in the video 

I review a New York Times article in the video and point to research on oats and celiac disease in the video description. These are the links I could verify. Do not read more into a paper than its title and abstract support.

Simar Bajaj, The New York Times (2026), "How Healthy Are Oats?": https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/13/well/eat/oats-health-benefits-recipes.html

Fric P, Gabrovska D, Nevoral J (2011), "Celiac disease, gluten-free diet, and oats": https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21294744/

Real A, Comino I, de Lorenzo L, et al. (2012), "Molecular and immunological characterization of gluten proteins isolated from oat cultivars that differ in toxicity for celiac disease": https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23284616/ (PMC3524229: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3524229/)

Silano M, Pozo EP, Uberti F, et al. (2014), "Diversity of oat varieties in eliciting the early inflammatory events in celiac disease": https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24240659/ (PMC4119590: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4119590/)

About Dr. Berry 

Dr. Ken Berry is a board-certified family physician who has cared for over 25,000 patients in more than two decades of practice in rural Tennessee. He grew up in Hohenwald, Tennessee, and earned his MD at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center. 

He is the author of the #1 bestselling Lies My Doctor Told Me and the creator of the Proper Human Diet. 

He lives on a farm in Holladay, Tennessee, with his wife Neisha and their two children.

Join me and thousands of others in the Proper Human Diet Community: 

If you have questions, you need answers to right now DrBerry AI will answer them 24/7